Fall 2024 Winner

Headshot of Hunter Hartley in a grey shirt with a grey background

My name is Miriam Koller, and I am a Chemistry major at the Colorado School of Mines with a passion for laboratory research. I aspire to become a pharmaceutical chemist, driven by the excitement of contributing to groundbreaking discoveries. Outside of the lab, I enjoy playing volleyball, painting, reading, and exploring Colorado’s beautiful outdoors. Originally from a Swiss family, I find a sense of home in the mountains that mirror my roots. I have lived in Colorado for most of my life.

Author’s Note:

When I initially began research for this paper, I knew that I wanted to discuss something related to air pollution, because I am very passionate about the environment, and I know a lot about greenhouse gas emissions as a Chemistry major. However, with every topic I delved into, most researchers agreed about the environmental impacts of a particular issue. I decided that I needed to adjust my perspective. Rather than just comparing the positive and negative ethics of the environment, I needed to compare two realms of ethics: environmental versus social. This changed mindset led me to the topic of electrification. This topic appealed to me as a relatively new driver looking to purchase a vehicle soon. My research question encouraged me to step out of my comfort zone as an environmental advocate and consider that there might be more to the topic than simply reducing air pollutants.

 

Should the United States encourage the production of more battery electric vehicles? 

In recent years, battery electric vehicles have been a major talking point in the transportation sector, with researchers, environmentalists, policy makers, and investors all holding varied opinions on their impact on society. The increased development and adoption rates of these cars stems from a desire to replace fossil fuels as the world’s primary energy source. With this shift in primary vehicles, the hope is to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and effectively combat the drastically rising issue of climate change. However, complete adaptation to battery electric vehicles is not a cut and dried solution to these issues. While professionals in the environmental field argue that a conversion to battery electric vehicles will better sustain the environment in the long run through reduced emissions, other experts in adjacent fields see a problem with encouraging the production of these vehicles, due to current methods of mineral sourcing. They acknowledge the potential of battery electric vehicles to positively impact the environment, but they don’t believe that these benefits are worth the human rights issues that arise from mining cobalt, copper, lithium, and other crucial minerals used in the production of batteries. This ethical debate has yet to be resolved; the advantages and consequences of battery electric vehicles continue to be weighed against each other, and scholars attempt to assert their arguments using synthesis of research and data to support their claims. Ultimately, good environmental ethics are not of enough significance to justify the implicit poor social ethics.  

Pro: Environmental Benefits of Battery Electric Vehicles 

Electric vehicle technology stemmed from wanting to protect the environment from human emissions. The damage that has been done to the environment in the form of resource depletion and air pollution cannot be reversed, but adjustments to human behaviors can prevent it from worsening further. José Alberto Fuinhas, an economist of energy policy, subscribes to this idea, claiming that battery electric vehicles have the capacity to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in the transportation sector and thus slow down climate change. He specifically lists carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous oxide, fluorinated hydrocarbons, and other chemicals as pollutants that “trap heat in the atmosphere,” and believes that battery electric vehicles can lessen those effects through zero exhaust emissions. Fuinhas uses quantile regression analysis to show the correlation between economic growth and an increase in greenhouse gas emissions in the European Union, but also illustrates that the conversion to battery electric vehicles combats these growing emissions. 

Pixabay | pexels.com

Although this report was collaborated on by engineers and environmentalists, Fuinhas’ lens may be more focused on fiscal matters and may not have authority on environmental impacts; his claims should be supported with other sources. Jeff Allen is the executive director of Forth (a trade association), and he endorses the same argument as Fuinhas, stating, “electrification is the only viable path forward in the face of concerns about air pollution and climate change.” Allen centers his writing around the concept of battery electric vehicles being a clean investment. While gasoline cars become “dirtier” with each year that they are in use, electric vehicles actually become increasingly environmentally-friendly as time passes, since the electric grid is continuously becoming cleaner. Allen’s writing from 2019 may be a bit outdated, but with increased advancements in electric technology, environmental benefits have only climbed. Fuinhas and Allen are in agreement about the environmental benefits of battery electric vehicles. They promote the production of more of these cars, speaking on their positive impact on the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions, and by extension, the slowing down of climate change. This extensive research is convincing, but it does not tell the whole story of electrification. Despite positive environmental impacts, promoting electric vehicles also leads to a disturbing human rights problem of child labor in resource extraction. One cannot justify valuing one side of ethics over the other. 

Environmentalists in support of battery electric vehicles acknowledge counterclaims about manufacturing emissions, yet use research and data to describe how the short-term pollution of electrification is quickly offset in the long run. Author Rachel Nealer drives this portion of the argument, with a joint Ph.D. in Civil and Environmental Engineering. Using life cycle assessments (LCAs) and a review of 51 lifecycle studies of hybrid and electric vehicles by Hawkins (et al.), Nealer is able to synthesize other research to illustrate her point. Even considering the manufacturing emissions, battery electric vehicles are shown to result in fewer greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline powered cars. Nealer says that “for a full-size 265-mile-range BEV…the extra manufacturing emissions are offset within 19,000 miles, or in about 16 months of driving. As illustrated by these statistics, the emissions from the production of electric vehicles are negligible when considering the full life-cycle of these cars. Although this report from 2015 may appear to be outdated, this evidence is supported by current sources; Fuinhas’s source from 2024 states that “BEVs currently have positive performance in reducing GHGs (between 30 and 80%) compared to gasoline ICEVs worldwide. No form of transportation will be emission-free, but battery electric vehicles are a step in the right direction, as their environmental benefits outweigh their short-term negative impact. Another common concern about electric vehicles is the short life-cycle of precious batteries, which Nealer works to put into perspective.

She describes that the lifetime of these batteries has been increasing over the years, with the vast majority of studies showing that the life cycle assessment of batteries has climbed so that only one battery is expected to be required per electric vehicle. Author Dana Lowell, a Zero Emission Advisor for WSP (an environmental consulting company), adds that as “battery technology improves” and “vehicle costs continue to decline,” electrification is made more accessible for those with lesser economic opportunity. Both Nealer and Lowell, with impressive and credible scholarly backgrounds, use synthesis of research to demonstrate how battery electric vehicles provide a cleaner alternative to gasoline cars, despite initial emission apprehensions. Electrification’s promise of a cleaner transportation life cycle would hugely benefit the global environment, but the issue of compromised social ethics, using child labor in resource extraction, remains as a problem. 

Environmentalists commonly use recycling procedures to support their arguments for battery electric vehicles. Author Anna Pražanová specializes in lithium-ion batteries recycling pre-treatment and sets forth the idea that recycling is a crucial aspect of battery electric vehicles having a net positive environmental impact. Materials for batteries need to be reused in order to minimize waste and production emissions, while also recovering valuable metals like “lithium (Li), cobalt (Co), nickel (Ni), and manganese (Mn).” Working to improve these recycling procedures for battery electric vehicles not only lessens their initial environmental impact in terms of manufacturing emissions, but also lowers resource extraction rates, protecting the natural world. The process of recycling in relation to electric vehicles is still being improved and implemented, but the systems that are already in place are working effectively and show promise for the future of salvaging components of batteries. In fact, through pyrometallurgical recycling, which uses high temperatures to extract raw metals, material recovery yields are observed to be over 90%. While expanded recycling may cause an economic burden, it certainly does have the capacity to lessen the environmental footprint of producing battery electric vehicles in the United States, and other areas of the world too. Pražanová’s competency in the subject area leads to a high degree of dependability of her arguments, which claim that the damage done to the environment to produce electric vehicles is quickly being addressed. Even so, the child labor involved in this resource extraction has not yet been successfully attended to, so wide-spread electrification should not be promoted. 

It is evident through the detailed research of these authors that battery electric vehicles do indeed have great potential for improving the environment, primarily through the lessening of greenhouse gas emissions. These benefits outweigh the initial manufacturing concerns and are supported further by recent implementations of recycling procedures, maximizing their value as alternatives to gasoline-powered cars. However, the ethics of protecting the environment must be weighed against the ethical concerns that arise from electrification; ultimately, the increased production of these vehicles should not be encouraged in the United States due to the jeopardization of human rights: child labor in resource extraction. 

Con: Human Rights Concerns from Resource Extraction for Battery Electric Vehicles 

Soley looking at the environmental benefits of electrification can be dangerous, as it may present an ideal view of these vehicles rather than showing an encompassing perspective of the topic. The environmentalist perspective touched on the idea of resource extraction, manufacturing emissions, and battery replacement for electric vehicles, yet categorized these factors as short-term impacts that are outweighed in the lifecycle of an electric car. Jonathan Wellings, with a lifecycle engineering doctorate, challenges this view of electrification and focuses on the matter of finite resources and material extraction. While the aforementioned improvements of battery lifetimes and recycling procedures help to reduce the waste generated from battery electric vehicles, these steps currently have a limited reach. Wellings emphasizes the sheer amount of material refuse that is produced from consumer-use of battery electric vehicles.

Even considering the increased lifetime of batteries, they still need to be replaced every couple of decades, with some batteries “losing approximately 30% of their capacity over 5–13 years of use. What’s more, not all consumers are willing to entertain the maintenance of these vehicles, and many will end up choosing to scrap their electric vehicle rather than replacing its battery. These replacements and scrapping of materials leads to a high degree of waste that cannot be completely addressed with recycling procedures, as suggested by the environmentalists. Not only is waste a concern, but in order to replace the used-up materials, new precious earth metals have to be obtained for production. These materials, like lithium, cobalt, and copper, are finite and need to be imported foreignly, raising an issue of unethical labor practices involved in mining. In essence, as the conversion to battery electric vehicles is encouraged, the waste generated and the demand for more resource extraction climbs drastically, creating concern for the ethics of electrification. While encouraging consumers in the United States to switch to electric vehicles has potential to diminish threats to the environment, this violates a guiding set of ethical standards, as doing so would result in abundant waste and human rights concerns. 

As the resource extraction mentioned above for battery electric vehicles continues to escalate, the concerns about human rights for mining labor are also heightened, with a specific focus on cobalt. Author Abby Goldman has a PhD focused on material science, and she details that many electric vehicle companies sign contracts “directly with mining/refining companies,” which implicitly involves them in whatever practices those companies employ. Unfortunately, many of these companies in the United States use the Democratic Republic of Congo as their primary supplier of cobalt materials, which has a reputation for human rights violations and child labor usage in resource extraction. Nick Bernards, a political economist, corroborates this point and provides more specific pieces of information related to this topic. He states that in two consecutive years in the 2010s (August 2016, November 2017), “Amnesty International (AI) issued reports highlighting labor abuses, particularly the prevalence of child labor, in cobalt mining in the Democratic Republic of the Congo. Due to the pressure of backlash, the DRC announced intentions to address these poor working conditions related to child labor in cobalt mining, but failed to deliver expectations.

With no labor inspectors or efforts to enforce higher standards, the issue remains unresolved, and the DRC ended up putting more energy into preserving their international image rather than addressing their complications in the labor sector.  Bernards also comments on the correlation between the increasing appearance of batteries for electric vehicles and the “cobalt mining boom in the DRC,” linking production companies to the human rights issue and giving them little room to escape responsibility. Bernards’ expertise in labor coincides well with the discussion of child labor related to cobalt mining in the DRC, giving him a considerable extent of credibility. In addition to Goldman and Bernards’ discussion of labor concerns, independent researcher Maria Sinclair endorses their arguments, using the example of Yantai Cash Industrial Company. Yantai Cash sells cobalt cathodes and is an approved delivery source for the London Metal Exchange.

Throughout their participation in the LME, Yantai Cash has been able to cause a “pricing differential” through the selling of a cheap product, which Sinclair says was made possible by their exploitation of child labor in the mining of cobalt. Moreover, Sinclair, focused on local and global policy, questions why Yantai Cash was not previously removed as a contributor to the LME, which Bernard answers in his own writing. The restrictions of the LME are principally concerned with “disclosure and auditing requirements and process standards” rather than labor conditions, showing how Yantai Cash took advantage of this lackluster structure of rules to avoid being cited as a violator. This proved to be a success, as Bernard states that this company appeared to have met all standards in the reports and was therefore not removed. Sinclair’s argument, paired with that of Goldman and Bernards, illustrates the haunting reality of child labor violations in the DRC and how the electrification companies in the United States and elsewhere are responsible through their tolerance of compromising human rights. The potential environmental benefits of electrification in the United States are not worth the social and ethical cost of prolonged child labor. 

Multiple smoke stacks during the sunset
Pixabay | pexels.com

The human rights concern in the Democratic Republic of Congo is more than a problem within the country; it extends to every electric vehicle company that uses DRC-mined cobalt in their batteries. These concerns are not just a question of morals, either. Companies are facing concrete consumer backlash over this, and are therefore losing support for their industry. Bernards states that in 2019, Tesla, among other technology companies, including Apple, Microsoft, and Dell, faced a lawsuit from human rights advocates in Washington. They sought “compensation for child labor and other abuses in cobalt mining for eventual use in their batteries on behalf of mining communities,” causing these companies not only to face monetary consequences, but also lose trust in their product.

 Filipe Calvão, with expertise in corporate responsibility of resource extraction, also speaks on this. He discusses a similar lawsuit filed in the United States against tech companies, which in turn brought “further attention” to the child labor violations in the Democratic Republic of Congo. This causes an infinite loop of sorts, as the increased attention led to even more consumer backlash. Because of this, a call to action for consumers is growing in the media, with companies being pressured to stop their inconsiderate imports of materials mined in unethical manners.  Calvão’s claims paired with Bernards’ insight into the issue show how deeply the United States is entrenched in human rights violations in the DRC. Without stopping child labor in resource extraction or finding a new supplier, electric vehicle companies cannot in good conscience encourage electrification, as it jeopardizes social ethics. 

Amnesty International (AI) issued reports highlighting labor abuses, particularly the prevalence of child labor, in cobalt mining in the Democratic Republic of the Congo.

It is glaringly obvious that the production of electric vehicles involves some unsettling practices. The Democratic Republic of Congo happens to be the world’s largest supplier of cobalt, a crucial mineral needed for manufacturing batteries, and uses cheap child labor to maximize their own gain. What’s more, these extraction companies are able to get away with this unethical implementation, through expert avoidance of global held standards. Because of this arising issue, electric vehicle companies in the United States who use DRC-supplied cobalt find themselves implicitly responsible for the human rights dilemma across seas. Electrification should not be encouraged in the United States, as doing so would display an acceptance of human rights violations. 

Conclusions: 

The controversy surrounding battery electric vehicles is not only a large dispute, but is also incredibly important and relevant for today’s population. With electric vehicles on the market in a higher proportion than ever before and dozens of car companies coming out with their very own models, the options have never been so diversified. Every new driver looking to purchase a mode of transport has to make the decision between a gasoline-powered car, a battery electric vehicle, or a hybrid, and by extension, has to weigh the pros and cons of each. While battery electric vehicles are shown to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and have the potential to slow down climate change, the intense resource extraction involved in their production and the human rights issues that respectively arise muddle the ethics of electrification. 

Authors in the environmentalist perspective highlight the zero-emission appeal of battery electric vehicles, minimizing pollutants from entering the atmosphere. What’s more, continuous improvements in a cleaner electric grid, battery life cycles, and recycling procedures further increase these environmental benefits, offsetting manufacturing emissions at an even quicker rate. Encouraging the production of more electric vehicles, in this sense, would be ethically positive for the environment. 

However, the environment is not the only factor to consider in this decision, which is where authors from the human rights perspective come in. Battery electric vehicles may have environmental benefits, but they also involve harsh resource extraction and material waste. What’s more, the metals mined for the production of batteries, specifically cobalt, involve compromising child labor laws in the Democratic Republic of Congo, implicitly involving electric vehicle companies in these violations. Encouraging the production of more electric vehicles cannot be done with a clear conscience, as it would demonstrate an acceptance of unethical social practices to obtain the necessary materials for vehicle batteries. 

Neither of these perspectives directly opposes each other, but rather, they view the weighing of outcomes differently. Whether battery electric vehicles have a net positive impact on the world cannot be decisively stated, but the benefits and drawbacks can be compared to each other. When considered holistically, the positive ethics of protecting the environment are simply not of enough significance to justify the jeopardization of human rights. Should companies in the United States be willing to accept higher import costs and find an ethically acceptable alternative to cobalt supply, then the controversy surrounding encouraged production of electric vehicles could be revisited.  

Associate Professor of Mining Engineering at Colorado School of Mines, Elizabeth Holley, wants to advocate for this change, too. Since most cobalt is recovered as a byproduct from nickel and copper mining, she sees potential for cobalt to be sourced directly from the United States. Many different minerals are capable of hosting cobalt, meaning that there are many different options for the future of mining materials for battery electric vehicles. Holley strongly believes that mining is not only about the resources gained, but also about the methods involved, who it impacts, and how it affects communities. This outlook needs to be incorporated into the production of battery electric vehicles, as allowing social ethics to be compromised for environmental gain is problematic.  

Electrification should not be encouraged in the United States, as the child labor practices for cobalt mining in the Democratic Republic of Congo are not worth the potential environmental benefits of replacing traditional gasoline cars. Cobalt is a crucial mineral used in the production of these vehicles, directly linking poor social ethics with electrification.

Refrences

Allen, Jeff. “Are Electric Cars the Future?” Environmental Forum, vol. 36, no. 2, Mar. 2019, pp. 36–57. EBSCOhost, research.ebsco.com/linkprocessor/plink?id=b8c70bcd-bc09-3a67-b56c-3fdb914764b1. Accessed 15 Sep 2024. 

Bernards, Nick. “Child labour, cobalt and the London Metal Exchange: Fetish, fixing and the limits of financialization.” Economy and Society 50.4 (2021): 542-564. Accessed 15 Sep 2024. 

Calvão, Filipe, et al. “Cobalt mining and the corporate outsourcing of responsibility in the Democratic Republic of Congo.” The Extractive Industries and Society 8.4 (2021): 100884. Accessed 15 Sep 2024. 

Fuinhas, José Alberto, et al. “Effect of battery electric vehicles on greenhouse gas emissions in 29 European Union countries.” Sustainability 13.24 (2021): 1361. Accessed 15 Sep 2024. 

Goldman, Abby R., et al. “The Electric Vehicle Battery Supply Chain.” Lithium Ion Battery Industrial Base in the U.S. and Abroad, Institute for Defense Analyses, 2019, pp. 9–26. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/resrep22804.5.  Accessed 15 Sep 2024. 

Hossain, M. S., et al. “Advancements and future prospects of electric vehicle technologies: a comprehensive review.” Complexity 2022.1 (2022): 3304796. Accessed  15 Sep 2024. 

Lowell, Dana, et al. “Policy Approaches—Clean Transportation for Rural Communities.” Clean Transportation Strategies for Rural Communities in the Northeast and Mid Atlantic States: With Analysis of Maine, Vermont, Virginia, and Maryland, Union of Concerned Scientists, 2020, pp. 20–39. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/resrep28303.7. Accessed 15 Sep 2024. 

Nealer, Rachael, et al. “Global Warming Emissions from Manufacturing Electric Vehicles.” Cleaner Cars from Cradle to Grave: How Electric Cars Beat Gasoline Cars on Lifetime Global Warming Emissions, Union of Concerned Scientists, 2015, pp. 16–24. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/resrep17225.8. Accessed 15 Sep 2024. 

Nealer, Rachael, and T. P. Hendrickson. “Review of recent lifecycle assessments of energy and greenhouse gas emissions for electric vehicles.” Current Sustainable/Renewable Energy Reports 2 (2015): 66-73. Accessed 15 Sep 2024. 

Pražanová, Anna, Vaclav Knap, and Daniel-Ioan Stroe. “Literature review, recycling of lithium-ion batteries from electric vehicles, part I: recycling technology.” Energies 15.3 (2022): 1086.Accessed 15 Sep 2024. 

Sinclair, Maria. “Seizing the Means of Production: Cobalt and the Electric Vehicle Sector.” China’s Uneven High-Tech Drive: Implications for the United States, edited by    Scott Kennedy, Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), 2020, pp. 42–46. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/resrep22605.14. Accessed 15 Sep 2024. 

Wellings, Jonathan, David Greenwood, and Stuart R. Coles. “Understanding the future impacts of electric vehicles—An analysis of multiple factors that influence the market.” Vehicles 3.4 (2021): 851-871. Accessed 15 Sep 2024.