Fall 2018 Winner

Graduation photo of Audrey Corzine

Hello! My name is Audrey Corzine. I obtained a Bachelor’s degree in Civil Engineering in 2022 in which I focused on the topic of Water Resources. I enrolled in the combined program and completed a Master’s degree in Hydrology in 2023 wherein I took great interest in water modeling courses. I grew up in Chillicothe, Ohio and moved to Colorado for college. I enjoy playing softball and pickleball, and I love to explore lakes and reservoirs throughout Colorado by paddleboarding and hiking. During college and after graduation, I have worked in the dam engineering industry as a hydrology & hydraulics engineer where I conduct hydrologic and hydraulic modeling (for both water and tailings dams), dam breach analyses and consequences, and design water conveyance components of dams such as spillways and outlet works. On top of that, I have been able to apply my skills and interests further to fish passage design. 

Author’s Note

When I moved to Colorado for college, I immediately noticed the stark contrast in the availability of water and the resulting need for more sustainable water use in the western states. The concern for water was continuously coming up as the Colorado River’s reservoirs were reaching extreme lows in 2018 right as I was moving into the state. At first I was curious as to how the water crisis in the West came about, but it led me to think about how the limited water supply was being used and therefore who and what was affected because of it. Professor Dr. Olivia Burgess helped guide my curiosity, which encouraged me to dive further into researching how California resorts to using groundwater due to the water crisis and investigating the parties affected because of the unsustainable use of groundwater over several years. The study of the depletion of groundwater in California enabled me to reason that the responsibilities of an engineer involved in the design of water conveyance structures or the study of water are to develop solutions to mitigate water use and loss as we experience harsher effects of climate change and to push for modern water data and research to support government water use regulations and allocations of the Colorado River and future crises that will arise. 

Who’s Left High & Dry – California’s Agriculture or Endangered Species? The Depletion of Groundwater in California

Take a walk on the dirt in San Joaquin Valley, California and one will hear the soil crumbling beneath their feet with each step. Take a look at California’s Lake Oroville and one will see the evidence of several hundred feet of lowered waters. All around California, ongoing drought conditions have created great concern for the groundwater supply. Thus, the state of California enacted its first groundwater protection law in 2014, the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act, as there continued to be a great reliance on groundwater as drought conditions had persisted since 2011. Drought conditions are so severe in California such that there is a great debate as to how the limited water supply should be apportioned: Should water go to California’s agriculture or to endangered species? With thirsty crops, farmers are desperate to allocate as much groundwater as possible to keep their crops thriving. On the other hand, environmentalists aim to protect the endangered fish species of California as groundwater dwindles.

The persistent need for groundwater has farmers drilling for gold in the form of water, ultimately making them prisoners to the commons dilemma as described by Garret Hardin in “The Tragedy of the Commons,” because farmers show no signs of stepping back from their groundwater wells. With each farmer acting under this rationale, the collective actions are undeniably limited to a finite resource. California’s farmers are drilling and pumping for more water as they try to maximize their own benefit; however, these interests are at odds with the long-term interests and the common good, like environmentalists who are working to protect endangered species. To keep farmers and environmentalists at ease in California, is it up to the government and their regulations, or is it up to the engineer whose purpose is to implement effective solutions, who is concerned for the problem in its longevity, and who can be respected by both sides? Ideally, engineers should have a say in the laws for groundwater management. Science and data should be implemented while formulating laws because the application of this information would adequately improve groundwater management.

“To keep farmers and environmentalists at ease in California, is it up to the government and their regulations, or is it up to the engineer whose purpose is to implement effective solutions, who is concerned for the problem in its longevity, and who can be respected by both sides?”

 

 

 

 

Background

California is no stranger to drought as it has experienced several extended periods of dry weather since 1985, with the driest period occurring in 1974-1977. California’s most recent drought began in 2011 and ended in 2017. At the beginning of the drought in 2011, California was increasing to a moderate drought classification and noted the second driest December on record. By January 2014, over sixty percent of California was experiencing extreme drought, the second to highest classification of a drought. With the severity of the drought, a statewide emergency was proclaimed by the governor. Less than a year later in August 2014, reservoirs were below fifty percent of their total capacity. There was a 6.6 million acre-foot reduction in surface water for agriculture. As a result, the loss of surface water was replaced with increased groundwater pumping by 5.1 million acre-feet. Fifty-eight percent of California was classified as exceptional drought by September 2014. From 2014 on, drought conditions began to reduce in severity in certain areas of the state. As a result, the statewide proclamation of emergency for the drought was lifted in 2017 (National Integrated Drought Information System).

Several factors played a role in California’s severe drought of 2011-2017. Due to climate change, there was a multi-year lack of precipitation from 2011 to 2014 and record high temperatures in 2014 and 2015 (National Integrated Drought Information System). Thus, climate change had an influence on surface and groundwater depletion. Groundwater is found in the earth between sand, soils, and fractured rock which makes up an aquifer, and layers of aquifers make up a groundwater basin. The relationship between surface water and groundwater is crucial. National Integrated Drought Information System states “when surface water in California’s reservoirs and rivers is low, groundwater found below the state’s surface becomes especially important.” In other words, when surface water is low following a period of drought, there is an increase in the use of groundwater. During an average year, around thirty-eight percent of groundwater is used for the state’s total water supply. Contrarily, up to forty-six percent or more of groundwater is used during dry years (National Integrated Drought Information System). As can be seen, groundwater is an essential buffer against the impacts of drought and climate change.

The depletion of groundwater is causing many problems in California. Groundwater is accessed through wells and pumps, and when it is extracted at a rate faster than it can be replenished, groundwater elevations decrease. When groundwater elevations decrease, the ground above begins to sink as well, known as land subsidence. Subsidence is occurring frequently in Central Valley where aqueducts and flood control structures are in danger of becoming damaged. In addition to land subsidence, the over-drafting of groundwater is causing a reduction in streamflow and lower lake levels, which puts aquatic ecosystems at danger (“Groundwater”). With the depletion of groundwater causing land subsidence and reduced water in rivers and lakes, many agricultural farms and many fish species are at risk in California.

The government’s water laws and policies did not often acknowledge that groundwater and surface water are inter-dependent. However, with the enactment of the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA) in 2014, the relationship between groundwater and surface water was finally acknowledged. The SGMA requires water users in over-drafted groundwater basins to make groundwater sustainability plans to be implemented to bring groundwater use into balance by 2040. Plans must be established to avoid undesirable effects from pumping, such as reduced streamflow and harm to groundwater-dependent ecosystems like rivers and wetlands (Mount).

Cracked earth from a drought

Markus Spiske | unsplash.com

Positions

Though it has only been four years since the enactment of the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act, farmers and environmentalists are eager for quick solutions to mitigate the depleting groundwater supply in California. How quickly can groundwater be restored? This is the question that is on the mind of farmers and environmentalists as the effects of groundwater depletion have become more visible in the recent drought. Farmers and environmentalists have been involved in an ongoing water war where when one side sees the benefit, the other sees the cost. If California’s groundwater problem cannot be resolved, there are concerns that other states who also rely heavily on groundwater will follow the same path. What’s going wrong in California? Framers believe that water is being diverted away from agriculture, and environmentalists believe water is being taken away from endangered fish species.

The Position of the Farmers

From the beginning of the 2011 drought, California’s farmers experienced diversions of their water supply. Victor Hanson, a farmer in California, wrote in his article “The Scorching of California” that farmers lost the early water “diversion battles” against environmentalists, and that he witnessed the effects of the water diversion first hand. Environmentalists wanted water from snowbelts stored in mountain dams to be diverted from agricultural use to replenish rivers. In doing so, water was freely flowing into the Pacific Ocean. Hanson stated the purpose for this diversion was because environmentalists “believed that vastly increased freshwater inflows would help oxygenate the San Francisco Delta, thereby enabling the survival of the Delta smelt, a three-inch baitfish, while ensuring that salmon could be reintroduced into the San Joaquin River watershed.” If the diversion had not occurred, the resulting flow of water could have created surface water that farmers could use instead of relying on groundwater to water their crops. Furthermore, former Representative Nancy Pelosi and Senator Barbara Boxer of California supported the river diversions at the time of their implementation. In Fresno County, federal programs whose purpose is to ensure groundwater aquifer sustainability stopped almost all surface water deliveries. The cut-off of water to farmers allowed water to be released in a major river nearby for habitat restoration. With this policy and others, Hanson’s water table located in his front yard remained about forty feet below the surface through 2012 (Hanson).

Farm in between corn plants with a straw hat on

Erik ✋ | unsplash.com

Hanson was not the only farmer affected by these policies that claim to be driven by environmentalists. With surface water not being supplied to farmers, they did not want to pay the taxes for irrigation. So, farmers resorted to pumping groundwater from the aquifers below. In focus groups conducted to collect the perspectives of farmers, farmers expressed their increasing reliance on groundwater. One farmer said, “We have a classic tragedy of the commons when you have groundwater down there, and we can’t all pump, pump and pump forever” (Niles). Indeed, this is an example of the tragedy of the commons. In Hardin’s paper “The Tragedy of the Commons,” he describes the scene of a common pasture that is “open to all,” and each herdsman will try to keep as many of their cattle on the commons as possible (105). Each herdsman is seeking to maximize his gain, just like farmers in California are trying to do for themselves. Hardin describes the “tragedy” of the commons being “parties’ individual calculuses of how to maximize their own benefit [always conflicting with] the global calculus of all parties together of how to maximize their collective best interest” (Cooper). Hardin argues the actions of self-interest will continue as long as the costs to the farmers individually are less than the benefits (107). Because the drying of groundwater is causing farmers to drill more and deeper wells, farmers are becoming prisoners to the commons dilemma.

In an agricultural town in California, for example, farmers are drilling wells approximately ten times deeper than the normal depth of wells. Though farmers know this is a “self-defeating pattern,” actions do not change because market incentives for profitable crops such as pistachios as well as drought conditions encourage farmers to keep pumping the groundwater (Cooper). Nonetheless, in the San Joaquin Delta, another agricultural part of California, 500 farmers voluntarily cut their water supply by twenty-five percent in accordance with the government so that their water supply would not be cut off (Cooper). The action of these farmers indicates they acknowledge the problem lies within their excessive pumping of groundwater, but this solution does not go as far to fully restore the commons.

The Position of the Environmentalists

Not all water diversions are assisting the environmentalists’ purpose of protecting endangered fish species in California, nor are all water diversions encouraged by environmentalists. Together, two federal and state water projects in the southern delta “export water from the delta south to supply some portion of the needs of more than twenty-seven million people and three million acres of farmland” (Levy). The export of water created more availability of surface water for farmers, thus their reliance on groundwater was reduced. However, because of these water diversions, many native fish are harmed since the amount of water flowing through the delta and out of the bay is significantly reduced.

The Delta smelt, an endangered native fish species, has been the target in arguments against the environmentalist’s purpose for water in the delta. The Delta needs fresh water so fish like the smelt can live in a habitat in which they are accustomed to, where there is a mix of both fresh and salt water. Sharon Levy reports in her case study “In the Fate of the Delta Smelt, Warnings of Conservation Gone Wrong” that a California reporter for The Western Farm Press stated “it would take about four average size minnow buckets to hold 305 3-inch Delta smelt, yet that is the number of minnows responsible for diverting enough water to the ocean to provide a year’s supply for 800,000 California families” (Levy). Water regulations that provide some aid to mitigate the depletion of endangered fish species in the delta have opponents such as the farmer who perceive the smelt as insignificant and care not to understand that smelt are not minnows.

Environmentalists from the California Sportfishing Protection Alliance who are working to restore the Delta state “California is in a water crisis because we have overpromised, wasted and inequitably distributed limited water supplies.” They go on to say, “the Delta is in a biological meltdown because the estuary has been deprived of more than half of its historical flow; its hydrograph (timing of flows) has been turned on its head and its waterways used as sewers” (“Stewardship”). State officials have not considered the separation between water needed to keep the delta fresh and water required to protect the fish within the Delta. These separate needs for water in the Delta have been noted by officials as “environmental water.” During the time of state’s most intense drought in 2014-2015, only 400,000 acre-feet of the 3.5 million acre-feet (ten percent) of export reductions aimed to keep the delta fresh were meant for fish (Levy). Most of the water diversions were already spelled out before California’s recent historic drought. A water quality plan was previously adopted in 2000 under the Clean Water Act stating requirements for keeping the delta water fresh for pumping water to be exported to other areas of California (Levy). Recently, farmers in San Joaquin Valley complained of pumping limitations and those who agreed argued it was to protect “a certain kind of 3-inch fish”. However, sixty-six percent of the water flowing downstream instead of being pumped was meant to keep the delta fresh of farm runoff and saltwater, and only thirty-three percent was to protect the fish (Levy).

“For the farmer and environmentalist, every drop of water counts, and they are searching for an efficient alternative to manage the water supply in California.”

 

 

 

River at sunset with trees and hills nearby

12019 | pixabay.com

Common Ground

As the state of California recovers from one of their most historic droughts from 2011- 2017, environmentalists and farmers look for answers as to went wrong with the water supply. Both witnessed the devastating effects that a drought can have on their purpose for water, whether it be agriculture or endangered fish species. California’s water projects should be designed to give the most beneficial outcome even with drought conditions, yet they have a give and take relationship with farmers and environmentalists. As farmers receive a larger allocation of surface water, environmentalists receive reduced streamflow. On the other hand, as environmentalists receive a larger allocation of water, farmers receive less surface water and thus their reliance on groundwater increases, repeating the cycle. It can be argued by both sides that water is being overallocated or under-allocated. According to the former assistant general manager of the Contra County Water District turned reporter Greg Gartrell, “I think we could start losing both species and farms if we don’t get this right” (Levy). The significance of his report is that it presents a neutral view of the situation. Not only do the people at stake see there is a problem with the allocation of water, but others outside of the problem see it as well. For the farmer and environmentalist, every drop of water counts, and they are searching for an efficient alternative to manage the water supply in California.

Solutions

With the direct association between surface water and groundwater, it is crucial that California makes the best decision when it comes to retaining the depleting groundwater supply. Government regulations can help solve the problem that farmers and environmentalists are hoping to resolve, as there are government officials whose job is to listen to their constituents to formulate groundwater regulations. The Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (2014) is a step in the right direction because of its demand for the quick establishment of plans for over- drafted and priority basins by 2020. The SGMA has potential in alleviating the feud for groundwater’s effects on surface water, but it is unlikely as previous government involvement has shown no signs of helping. The act was California’s panic button when the drought was at its peak in 2014. Consequently, what each stakeholder wanted from the SGMA was not fully implemented in the design, and the act was not formulated with the latest science and data available. As reported by the Government Accountability Office, “existing data [for groundwater] are limited or of poor quality” (Breggin).

California needs a more effective solution that will adequately implement science and data into water regulations, but most importantly, groundwater regulations. Laws should reflect scientific knowledge by managing aquifers based on each of their conditions and characteristics. Not just one type of aquifer regulation should apply to all aquifers, and water regulations should consider climate change as it is becoming a significant influencer of drought. For the propositions as mentioned above to take place, it requires the work of engineers.

Engineers are most capable and prepared for the task of applying science and gathering data which will alleviate California’s depleting groundwater supply. Engineers entail value- sensitive design in which the farmers and environmentalists of California can benefit greatly. In an article written by Ronald Sandler titled “Value-Sensitive Design and Nanotechnology,” Sandler addresses the strong correlation between how engineering shapes society. He states, “Engineers make use of scientific and mathematical knowledge to devise technological solutions” (73). The value-sensitive design enables engineers and developers to give conflicting social values a place in smart design and to combine them is such a way as to reach a win-win situation in California. This design approach by engineers situates moral questions early in the process of design, development of technologies, systems and research for California’s aquifers. With the engineers’ moral rationale, farmers and environmentalists will benefit immensely because their social values will be integrated into the design process for groundwater projects.

Currently, engineers are helping save California’s groundwater supply by developing unique and efficient ways in which water can be saved and stored. Robert Reid, the author of “Engineering for Every Drop,” discusses the many ways in which civil engineers are helping to mitigate water use and loss. Civil engineers in California “are helping farmers switch to water- saving drip irrigations, lining earthen canals with concrete to reduce losses from seepage, and even exploring the possibility of covering surface canals with photovoltaic panels,” says Reid (54). With engineers putting more focus on the farmers, the farmers can escape the prisoner’s dilemma that is leading them to a race to the bottom of the commons. Additionally, environmentalists will likely see higher river and lakes levels as engineers are working to preserve surface water by covering the Los Angeles Reservoir with approximately one-hundred million plastic balls. It is estimated that this project will save three-hundred million gallons of water annually because of the reduction in evaporation.

Within Reid’s article, he quotes Benjamin I. Cook, Ph.D., an atmospheric research scientist associated with NASA. Dr. Cook stated, “the water is overallocated, and on top of that there’re all sorts of political agreements between states, between municipalities, and even between the US and Mexico that complicate who gets water and when [during these dry periods]” (48). Cook argues the same point as farmers and environmentalists and calls attention to the flaws of the government. Utilizing the data that scientist Dr. Cook has articulated during his research, engineers can design projects that will efficiently manage surface water and groundwater. Once the government begins applying the scientific data and projects into water regulation, both farmers and environmentalists should no longer have conflicting views.

Conclusion

California’s drought has pitted farmers against environmentalists over the use of water. However, the blame for the tragedy of the commons that lies beneath the soil cannot solely be put on the farmers. The state’s water diversions have farmers and environmentalists thinking the other is to blame, yet the culprit it is the discrepancy of water regulations. With climate change causing worse and more common drought conditions, water diversions need to be more corresponding to the needs of farmers and environmentalists. If the government begins remediating water regulations by taking scientific data and engineering projects into account, it will mean the commons has a chance of restoration. If the government continues to base water regulations off outdated science, groundwater will ultimately vanish, and both farmers and environmentalists will be left high and dry. Worst of all, the many harmful effects of groundwater depletion will become evident to all of California. The application of science and engineering into water regulations can provide effective solutions to other states that are heavily dependent on groundwater. The path that California chooses to take will undoubtedly affect many people in the Western United States.

Works Cited

Breggin, Linda K. “Groundwater issues present challenges.” The Environmental Forum, Nov.-Dec. 2014, p. 12. Print. Academic

OneFile, http://link.galegroup.com/apps/doc/A433017692/AONE?u=colomines&sid=AONE&xid=7cd268f6. Accessed 16 Oct. 2018.

Cooper, Elizabeth, Shafiqul Islam and Larry Susskind. “Emergence, Self-Organization and the Commons: Analyzing Complex

Water Management Problems.” Water Diplomacy, 3 Dec 2018. Web. Retrieved from http://blog.waterdiplomacy.org/2015/12/emergence-self-organization-and-the-commons-analyzing-complex-water-management-problems/. Accessed 16 Oct. 2018.

“Groundwater.” California Department of Water Resources, 2018. Web. Retrieved from

https://water.ca.gov/WaterBasics/Groundwater. Accessed 16 Oct. 2018.

Hanson, Victor D. “The Scorching of California.” City Journal, 2015. Web. Retrieved from https://www.city-

journal.org/html/scorching-california-13704.html. Accessed 16 Oct. 2018.

Hardin, Garrett. “The Tragedy of the Commons.” Nature and Human Values: A Student Guide. Ed. Cortney Holles. Plymouth:

Hayden-McNeil, 2018. 102-114. Print. Accessed 16 Oct. 2018.

Levy, Sharon. “In the Fate of the Delta Smelt, Warnings of Conservation Gone Wrong.” Undark, 23 April 2018. Web. Retrieve from

https://undark.org/article/delta-smelt-california-endangered/. Accessed 16 Oct. 2018.

Mount, Jeffrey. “The Connection between Groundwater and Surface Water.” Public Policy Institute of California, 2018. Web.

Retrieved from http://www.ppic.org/blog/the-connection-between-groundwater-and-surface-water/. Accessed 16 Oct. 2018.  

National Integrated Drought Information System. “California is no stranger to dry conditions, but the drought from 2011-2017 was

exceptional.” US Drought Portal, 2018. Web. Retrieved from https://www.drought.gov/drought/california-no-stranger-dry-conditions-drought-2011-2017-was-exceptional. Accessed 16 Oct. 2018.

Niles, Meredith T., and Courtney Hammond Wagner. “Farmers share their perspectives on California water management and the

Sustainable Groundwater Management Act.” California Agriculture, vol. 70, no. 4, 2018, p. 38+. Agriculture Collection, http://link.galegroup.com/apps/doc/A532418264/PPAG?u=colomines&sid=PPAG&xid=1ace8bf5.  Accessed 16 Oct. 2018.

Reid, Robert L. “Engineering for every drop.” Civil Engineering, vol. 85, no. 10, 2015, pp. 46-55 Print. Academic OneFile,

http://link.galegroup.com/apps/doc/A437018315/AONE?u=colomines&sid=AONE&xid=3b8c7ce8. Accessed 16 Oct. 2018.

Sandler, Ronald. “Value-Sensitive Design and Nanotechnology.” Nature and Human Values: A Student Guide. Ed. Cortney Holles.

Plymouth: Hayden-McNeil, 2018. 69-86. Print. Accessed 16 Oct. 2018.

“Stewardship Council Delta Plan Campaign.” California Sportfishing Protection Alliance, 2011. Web. Retrieved from

http://calsport.org/news/stewardship-council-delta-plan-campaign/. Accessed 16 Oct. 2018.